Mailbox replacement pricing
How much does mailbox replacement cost?
Mailbox replacement with OnlyMailboxes usually matches our installed package pricing: $497, $897, $1,147, or $1,397 depending on the selected mailbox and post system. Booking is 50% down with the balance due after installation.
Priority service territory: Chicagoland suburbs within about 15–20 miles of Homer Glen. Our Homer Glen address is an office/service-area address, not a walk-in showroom.
The short answer
A replacement is the right fit when your mailbox is damaged, outdated, leaning, or no longer fits your home. We remove the old setup, install the new mailbox package, and leave the curb area clean.
Installed replacement packages: $497, $897, $1,147, or $1,397.
These pages are written for homeowners comparing actual installed cost, not just the shelf price of a mailbox at a big-box store.
Pricing options
Standard Replacement
$497
fully installed
- Installed mailbox replacement
- Old mailbox removal
- Great for clean, simple upgrades
- 50% deposit to book
Classic Replacement
$897
fully installed
- Decorative post-mounted options
- Premium curb appeal
- Professional removal and install
- 50% after installation
Deluxe Replacement
$1,147
fully installed
- Upgraded package choices
- Durable mailbox and post systems
- Neighborhood-friendly fit
- Local installation crew
Premium Replacement
$1,397
fully installed
- Statement mailbox packages
- High-end curb appeal
- Removal and installation included
- Clear 50/50 payment schedule
What changes a mailbox replacement price?
- Selected replacement mailbox package
- Whether the existing post is loose, rotted, or set in heavy concrete
- Driveway, curb, or landscaping constraints
- Subdivision or HOA style requirements
- Add-ons such as address plaques or upgraded hardware
How it works
- 1Send a photo of your current mailbox and preferred replacement style.
- 2We confirm the installed price and available schedule.
- 3You pay a 50% deposit to reserve your spot.
- 4We replace the mailbox and collect the balance after completion.
Frequently asked questions
Is old mailbox removal included?
Yes, standard old mailbox removal and cleanup are included with our installed replacement packages unless there are unusual site conditions.
Can you replace a mailbox after it was hit by a car or snowplow?
Yes. We can replace damaged mailbox setups and can also provide documentation helpful for insurance or responsible-party reimbursement when needed.
How soon can you replace my mailbox?
Scheduling depends on route availability and product selection. Our priority service area is the Chicagoland suburbs near Homer Glen, which helps us keep replacement scheduling efficient.